Back to comparisons

SKNK Field Notes · Point by point

Own ASN and Provider-Managed Routing

Routing identity, BGP configuration, incident response, and network-change dependencies define the operational ownership model.

Reviewed against public documentation: 2 August 2026

Compare point by point

Every point is concrete work.

Routing identity

Option one · Own ASN and external routing policy

Your organisation uses its own ASN or another documented routing identity.

Option two · Provider-managed routing

The provider supplies the routing identity within its documented service scope.

BGP configuration

Option one · Own ASN and external routing policy

Your team configures and operates BGP with compatible upstreams.

Option two · Provider-managed routing

The provider runs the routing service inside its stated scope.

Routing policy

Option one · Own ASN and external routing policy

Your organisation defines the target policy within upstream acceptance and filtering conditions.

Option two · Provider-managed routing

The provider's product and policy set the available announcements and changes.

Operational work

Option one · Own ASN and external routing policy

Your team owns configuration, monitoring, incident response, and coordination.

Option two · Provider-managed routing

The provider's published service boundary and agreement allocate responsibility.

Where this model fits

The actual network determines the fit.

An own-ASN model fits networks that need to define an external routing policy across compatible upstreams.

Provider-managed routing fits a documented service boundary where the provider carries routing work.

Confirmation items before an application or change

These three facts shape the next steps.

1

Routing identity portability at service end

2

Upstream acceptance of the planned prefix and origin ASN

3

Operational changes caused by new upstreams, prefix changes, or service exit

This guide organises the decision points; formal pages and agreements provide the binding details.

Policies, resource relationships, service boundaries, and upstream filters vary by situation. Formal pages and the responsible party confirm price, eligibility, ownership, and service-end arrangements.

SKNK · Sources and scope

Sources and scope for this comparison

Each source supports one kind of conclusion. Source pages, registry records, and routing observations update at different times, so read every result with its source and timestamp.

RIPE Database

Registry and IRR records

Primary object documentation

Useful for checking

Whether a public object exists for this ASN or prefix, who it is registered to, and who maintains it.

Needs a separate check

Live BGP observations show the current announcement state.

SKNK support policy

Current service boundaries

Read support policy

Useful for checking

What SKNK publicly states about BGP and network-operations responsibility.

Needs a separate check

Each upstream provides its own acceptance and filtering policy.